---
source_url: "https://www.snai.edu/en/2004/1128/74046.shtml"
title: "Financial Stability in Emerging Markets:  The Unfinished Agenda--Khalid A. Mirza"
meta_description: "Khalid A. Mirza of the World Bank spoke at the 2004 APEC Finance and Development Program Annual Forum on financial stability in emerging markets. He noted the World Bank tracked nearly 120 financial crises in 93 countries over 25 years, each costing an average 16% of GDP, with cleanup exceeding a trillion dollars."
publish_date: "2004-11-28"
modify_date: "2025-11-07"
author: "上海国家会计学院"
publisher: "上海国家会计学院"
category: "News"
language: "zh-CN"
priority: 0.5
---

# Financial Stability in Emerging Markets:  The Unfinished Agenda--Khalid A. Mirza
> Khalid A. Mirza of the World Bank spoke at the 2004 APEC Finance and Development Program Annual Forum on financial stability in emerging markets. He noted the World Bank tracked nearly 120 financial crises in 93 countries over 25 years, each costing an average 16% of GDP, with cleanup exceeding a trillion dollars.

## 一、详细说明 
|  |
| --- |
| FinancialStabilityinEmergingMarkets:TheUnfinishedAgendaKhalidA.Mirza·Inthefirstplace,IwouldliketothanktheSecretary-GeneraloftheAPECFinanceandDevelopmentProgramforinvitingmetospeakatthe2004AnnualForum.Thisisarareprivilege.·IamalsogratefultotheSecretariatforaskingmetospeakonthequestionoffinancialstabilityinemergingmarketswhichisanareathatisverymuchapartofmyresponsibilitiesintheWorldBankinsofarastheEastAsiaandPacificregionisconcerned.Inmycurrentposition,IhaveprimaryresponsibilityforfinancialsectorandprivatesectordevelopmentinthisregionwhichcertainlymeansthatissuesoffinancialstabilitythataffectdevelopingcountriesofEastAsiaareofdirectrelevancetomywork.MypresentationwillalsoessentiallyfocusonemergingmarketcountriesofEastAsia.·Justtohighlighttheenormityoftheissueoffinancialstability,ImightmentionthattheWorldBankhastrackedcloseto120financialsystemcrisesin93countriesover,say,thepastquarterofacenturywitheachofthesecriseshavingcosttheaffectedcountriesanaverageof16%ofGDP.Theoverallaggregatebudgetarycostofcleaningupthesecrisesindevelopingcountriesismorethanatrilliondollars.Interestingly,thisisaboutequaltothetotaldevelopmentalassistanceprovidedtodevelopingcountriesinthesecondhalfofthe20thcentury.·Themulti-country,1997-98Asianfinancialcrisis,wasreallyoneofseveralsuchwavesoffinancialcrises,albeitthiswasprobablythemostwidespread.Itisalsothecrisisthatgottheworldtositupandnoticeandtoreachtheconclusionthatfosteringfinancialstabilitydeservesinternationalattentionandproddingasaglobalissueinwhichallcountrieshaveacommonalityofinterest.·Thenaturalquestionis:whataretheprobablecausesofturbulenceorcrisesinafinancialsystem?Wherearethevulnerabilitiesthatneedtobeaddressedandresolvedsothatthesystemremainstroublefree?Theanswerstothislineofrhetoricalquestioningare,inmostinstances,bothquiteobvious,andatthesametime,incomplete.·Ithinkeventhemostminimalapplicationofmindbyanyreasonablycompetentfinanceprofessionalwouldrevealwhateverisspecificallyweakorwrongoruntowardinafinancialsystemthatneedstobesortedouttopreventtroublefrombrewing.Andthereare,ofcourse,over-arching,well-recognizedcausalitiesforfinancialsystemfailuree.g.macro-economicimbalances,includingfiscalanomalies,thatcouldproduceconsiderablestressinthebankingsystem.Further,whilethereisconsiderablebeneficialimpacttobederivedfromaheighteningoftechnologicalsophisticationorfromenhancingscale,andofcourse,globalization,theinabilityofthefinancialsystemtoadequatelyrespondoradjusttothechangearisingfromthesedevelopmentsisoftencitedasbeingresponsibleforsystemicmalfunctioning.·However,moreoftenthannot,almostinvariably,afinancialcrisishitsacountryunawares,fromsourcesquiteunexpected.Whattriggersacrisisisalmostalwaysasurprise!Ofcourse,onceitoccurs,ithastobetackledwithbothemergentandlongertermmeasures,andthefaultlinessquarelyaddressed.Concurrently,thebigissueishowtocontainthecrisisandnotallowittospreadtootherjurisdictionsthatareperceivedtoexhibitthesameorsimilardeficiencies.Suchinternationalcontagion,firstseenin1994-95,duringtheTequilacrisis,andlaterintheAsianfinancialcrisisof1997-98,isaworrisomecharacteristicofincreasingglobalization,andthisisindeedtheprimaryconcernoftheinternationalcommunitydrivingavarietyofglobalinitiativessuchasthesettingupoftheManilaFrameworkGroupandtheFinancialStabilityForumaswellasmeasurestoreformtheinternationalfinancialarchitecturebytheG-20,andalsomoreconcertedmovesbytheinternationalfinancialinstitutionstoengenderfinancialstabilityinthecountriesbeingservedbythem.·Now,letmeturntosomeofthefundamentalsunderlyingfinancialstabilityandtowhatextenthasprogressbeenachievedbyemergingmarketcountries,particularlythoseintheAsiaPacificregion:·FIRST,macro-economicstability,includingfiscalhealth,andsoundmanagementofexchangerate,reserves,anddebtpoliciesareessential.Asageneralrule,unlesstherearegoodreasonstoproceedotherwise,flexibleexchangerateregimesarebestforemergingmarketeconomies,andofcourse,thereisconsensusthatprudentdebtandliquiditymanagementisakeyelementincrisisprevention.·Itmustbenotedthataliberalizedfinancialsystem,withallitsbenefits,ispronetoreactstronglytoaloss,orevenaperceivedlossofmacro-economicstability,andconverselyifmacro-economicpoliciesaresound,aliberalizedfinancialsystemwouldmeanverymuchlessfrequentandlessprotractedfinancialsectordisturbances.Itisnoteworthyherethatinrecentyearstheregionhasseen,barringveryfewcountries,significantimprovementsinmacro-economicmanagementwhichaugurswellforfinancialstability.InmostEastAsiancountries,theeconomicparameterswithinwhichthefinancialsectoroperates,haveimprovedsubstantiallywithpositiveimplicationsfortherisksbornebythefinancialsector.·SECOND,theregulatoryagenciesmustbecompetent,theymustbedulyempowered,andbeindependentaswellasfullycoordinatedwitheachother.Thisisperhapsthemostcriticalaspectoffinancialstabilityandcannotbeemphasizedenough.Whilerigidandprescriptive,merit-based,regulatorysystemsaredistortionaryandpronetocauselosses,aflexible,progressive,disclosure-basedregulatorystructureworksbestandisconducivetoreducingthecontentofriskinaliberalizedfinancialsystem.Further,theregulatoryagenciesmusthavedemonstratedcapacitytocarryoutcrediblemonitoring,surveillance,andenforcementactivitiesandaboveallmustnotonlybeindependentbutmustbeclearlyseentobeindependent.Regulatoryagenciesmusthavetheautonomy,therequisiteauthorityandtheprofessionalcompetencetorespondintimelyandadroitmannertochangesintheexternalandinternalenvironmentinordertomaintainthesafetyandsoundnessofthesystem.·Steadydevelopmentofthefinancialsystemandareductioninsystemicriskisachievedbyaregulatorystyle,thatinsteadofsecond-guessingeverydecisionofbanksandothermarketparticipants,createsincentivesandinformationstructuresthatallowmarketparticipantstoseeksensibleriskadjustedchoices.Inaddition,itisabsolutelycriticalthatinthispresenteraofinstitutionalintegrationandfinancialsupermarkets,financialsectorregulatoryagenciescoordinatecloselywitheachothersothattheregulationachievedissubstantivelyholisticandseamlesstherebyalsoensuringthatnothingfallsthroughthecracks,asitwere,andthechancesofregulatoryarbitragearediminished.Ifanemergingmarketisabletoputinplaceanedificeofregulationthatiseffectiveandclearlyindependent,morethanhalfthebattletoachievefinancialstabilityiswon.·AnditisinthisareathatEastAsiancountriesappearweakest.MostregulatoryagenciesintheregionarecontrolledbytheGovernmentandarethussubservienttopoliticalagendas.Theirregulatorycapacityneedsconsiderablestrengtheningandcoordinationamongstthedifferentregulatoryagenciesiseithernon-existentorinadequate.And,ifImaysayso,investorconfidenceandfinancialstabilitywillremain“elusive”unlessregulatorystandardsareraisedtoanacceptablelevelthroughouttheregion.·THIRD,anotheressentialelementtoensurefinancialstabilityandlessenthepossibilityofcrisesistheexistenceofstrongandcapablymanagedfinancialinstitutionswhichoperatewithinanincentiveframeworkthatpromotesefficiency,prudentialrisktaking,andprofitability.Here,byfinancialinstitutions,Inotonlymeanbanksandlendinginstitutionsbutalsoinstitutionsprovidingnon-lendingfinancialservicesorthosethatarecloselyinter-twinedwiththefinancialsystemlikeinvestmentbanks,securitiescompanies,assetmanagementcompanies,collectiveinvestmentinstitutions,insurancecompanies,leasingcompanies,factoringcompaniesandalsoinstitutionssuchasstockexchanges,creditratingagencies,creditbureaus,depositories,clearingandsettlementagenciesetc.Everyjurisdictionneedsawholesomeinstitutionalframeworkthatadequatelycoversallaspectsofthefinancialsystem.·Anunbalancedfinancialsystemskewedtowards,say,bankingdoesnothavethecomprehensiveprofiletohandlealldimensionsofrisk;and,asaconsequencebankingcomesunderalotofstrain.Ifyouputthisalongsidelendingpromptedbydubiouspoliticalinterventionsandcronyismandthemoralhazardassociatedwithimplicitorexplicitgovernmentcreditguaranteesyouhaveacrisisinthemaking.Inanycase,whetherornotthesenegativesexist,thereisaclearneedforfinancialsystemswithdepth---thatofferawide-rangeofproductsandinstrumentalitiestonotonlyprudentlyaddressvaryingriskpreferencesandengageinrisk-adjustedresourceallocationbutalsohavetheversatilitytocushiontheill-effectsarisingfromadisturbanceinanypartofthesystem.·Ihavetosaythatthefinancialsystemsinmostemergingmarketsareunbalancedandlackdepth.InEastAsia,thereisaheavydominanceofbankintermediationwhichinseveraljurisdictionsisconcentratedinstate-ownedbanks,albeittherearesporadicinstancesofafewnon-bankingsegmentsthathavegrownrapidlyinrecentyearsbutinanenvironmentofpoorregulatoryoversightandweakriskmanagementcapacity.While,followingthecrisis,therewerefairlydecisivestepstakentoresolvedistressedassetsandanumberofotherstepstakentorestorethehealthofbankinginstitutions,itisobviousthat,byandlarge,thereisstillalotofgroundtobecoveredbeforebankinginEastAsiacanbesaidtohavebeenrestoredtoanevenkeel.·Also,therearestillalargenumberofcorporationswithfragilebalancesheetsalbeitthebasicbusinessmodelsaresound---whilethesecorporatesmaynotbefullybankabletheycouldverywellbeappropriateclientsforcertaintypesofnon-bankinginstitutions.Unfortunately,howevernon-bankingremainslargelyweakorinadequate.·Furthermore,InotethatemergingmarketsinEastAsia,asinotherregions,havestockexchangesthatareeitherrunbyGovernmentorbystockbrokersneitherofwhichisahealthysituation.Thereareveryfewdemutualizedexchangesalbeitthetrendistowardsdemutualization.Allofthisaddsuptoaninstitutionalstructurewhichhastoimprovealotbeforeitreachesanoptimallevelofsophisticationandcontributestoreducingthevulnerabilityofthefinancialsystemtoexternalshocks.·FOURTH,anothersignificantelementthathasamarkedbearingonfinancialstabilityistheadequacyofgovernance.Itisimportantforfinancialinstitutionstoadheretotheprinciplesofsoundgovernanceandhavesystemsthataretransparent,thatcallfordueprocess,thatenhanceaccountability,thatprovideforadequateparameterstoresolveconflict,andthatprovideafairreturntoallstakeholders.Ofcourse,goodgovernancealsomeanstheapplicationofacceptableaccountingstandardsandsoundprocessesthatensurereliableauditsorelsethenecessarydegreeofdisclosureandtransparencywillbemissing.·Wehaveseenthattheabsenceofadherencetonormsofsoundcorporategovernanceresultsincronyism,unwarrantedpoliticalinterventions,conflictedsituations,acultureoffavors,andperhapsevencorruptpractices.Allthisunderminesthehealthoffinancialinstitutionsandrendersthemlesscapableofprovidingtheservicestheyaremandatedtoprovideaswellasmuchmorevulnerabletoexternalshocks.Also,clientsoffinancialinstitutionsthatarenotincompliancewithcorporategovernancenormsaregenerallylessstableandriskiertheobviousconsequenceofwhichisweakerportfoliosoffinancialinstitutionswithsystemicimplications.Furthermore,financialinstitutionsthatareessentiallypublicutilities,likestockexchanges,mustbefairlyrobustinthematterofcorporategovernancewithcapableandindependentchiefexecutives,otherwiseinvestorconfidencewouldbeadverselyaffected.·Inregardtocorporategovernancealso,alotofprogresshasbeenmadeinvariousjurisdictionsandthesituationinEastAsianowiscertainlyanimprovementoverwhatwasextantpriortothecrisisof1997-98.However,onestillobservessomepersistenceofgovernancestructuresthatprecededthecrisisandtheconsequentpotentialforinstabilityandprecipitationofsystemicriskremainsacauseforconcern.·IhavetouchedsomeoftheaspectsthatarerelevanttofinancialstabilityinEastAsiawithrespecttowhichfurtherprogressisneededinorderfordevelopingcountriesintheregiontobeabletowithstandthekindsofexternalshocksthatcouldcauseacrisisinavulnerableeconomy.Thekeytopreventingfuturefinancialcrisesisforemergingmarketeconomiestoinstitutesounddomesticeconomicpolicies,tobuildrobust,well-governedfinancialinstitutions,andtoputinplacecapable,fullyempowered,andindependentregulators.Noimprovementsintheinternationalfinancialarchitecturecanmakeupfordeficienciesinthesecrucialareasthat,inthecaseofEastAsia,hadledtospeculativeexcessesinassetmarketsandpoorriskmanagement.·Attheendoftheday,investorconfidenceisakeyelementinpromotingfinancialstability.TheessentialimpactofthefourelementsIhavediscussed,namely---soundmacro-economicpolicies,competentandautonomousregulators,robustfinancialinstitutions,andgoodcorporategovernance---isthestrengtheningofinvestorconfidence.Eveniftheseaspectsarenotfullyinplacebutsufficientprogresshasbeenmadesoastoengenderthenecessaryconfidenceinthesystem,anysudden,exogenous,negativedevelopmentsorforthatmatteranyegregiousattemptsbysignificantmarketplayerstoprecipitateacrisisareboundtofail.·Currently,theoutlookforglobalfinancialmarketsappearsquitebenignalthoughitrestsonaveryfinebalancingofopposingeconomicforces.Also,asagroupemergingmarketcountrieshavegreatlyimprovedtheireconomicfundamentalswhichhasreducedtheiroverallexternalvulnerability.However,thismasksawideninggulfbetweenthosethathavemadesignificantprogressandthosethathavenot.ThisistrueofEastAsiaaselsewhereinotherregions.·Thereareanumberofrisksthatdoyensoffinancialstabilitycurrentlytalkaboute.g.anoticeable“herding”intoriskyandunfamiliarassetsbyinvestorsseekinghigheryieldsincircumstancesofabundantliquidity;theincreasingtransferofrisks,inparticularcreditrisk,frombankingtonon-bankingsectorsi.e.fromrelativelymoreregulatedandtransparentinstitutionstorelativelylessregulatedandtransparentinstitutions;afurthersuddenfallintheUSDollarthatcouldoccurifcapitalflowsintotheUSdeclinesharply;afurthersubstantialincreaseinoilprices;heavilyindebtedoverinvestmentinpoorqualityassetsinsomecountries;andotherriskfactors.Asyet,alltheseandsimilarrisksareexpectedtohaveadverserepercussionsbutperhapsnotofcrisisproportions.Thisismyownviewaswellnotwithstandingthefactthatitisquitecommonforfinancialsystemproblemstobeidentifiedandequallycommonforthemtobeminimizedforonereasonoranother.AsIsaidearlier,boththecauseandthenatureofafinancialcrisisisunpredictable---usuallynotforeseenbymostpundits.Itis,therefore,essential---asIsaidearlieron---totakeaholisticapproachandstrengthenallpartsandsignificantaspectsofthefinancialsystemasabulwarkagainstanyuntowarddevelopmentsthatcouldcauseaturbulenceinthesystem.·Iwould,ofcourse,beveryhappytorespondtoanyquestionsorcomments. |

## 二、引用与来源
- 原文来源：<>
- 机构：上海国家会计学院
- 版权声明：上海国家会计学院版权所有
